J. L. Spohr
  • Blog
  • Books
    • Sword & Shield
    • Heirs & Spares
    • God & King
    • Crown & Thorns
    • Folke
  • About
    • Contact
  • News/Events

50 Shades of Slut Shame

2/20/2015

5 Comments

 
Picture
Yes. I read the book. All three in fact. I had to for my job as producer and host of a podcast about ideas that matter in culture. I got a lot of grief producing that show. We were known for plumbing the artistic and theological depths and how dare we give air time to the likes of "that" book? 

Of course, we did do a show on The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo with nary a peep of protest. A book which depicts brutal rape, gruesome detailed descriptions of sexualized murder, a nearing Boomer sleeping with every woman in his path, including the nubile, barely twenty-something Girl, and sprinkled liberally with multiple male fantasy lesbian sex scenes. 

Picture
Where was all the protest on that one? It was made in to films on each side of the Atlantic, with barely a whisper of offense. Indeed, author Stieg Larson was held up like Eddie Vedder above a mosh pit as a feminist poster boy. His heroine is bold, stands up to men, makes her own rules. And yet, Lisbeth Salandar is a shell of a human being, so hollowed out by horror that her only motivation for even breathing is violence and vengeance. The perfect picture of the modern women. How dare we call his book's sexual content in to question? It's art. He's a man, so he should know.

Which brings me to my frustration with all this 50 Shades of Grey hate: since it is a book about a woman enjoying lots and lots of sex, written by a woman, it is automatically wrong, wrong, wrong. Because woman are either virgins or whores and there is no in between. 

Picture
Even feminists are pouring on the hate. And I get it, we've been fighting against the misconception that domination by males is What Women Want. We don't want the Second Wave sexual revolution to be based on women "submitting." We want to be unshackled in our sexual freedom, not blindfolded and trussed up like a Thanksgiving turkey for a man drooling like Wile-E Coyote.

And yet, if you read the books, the heroine's goal is to actually lift Mr. Grey out of his domineering ways and, of course, she eventually succeeds...along the way, she surprisingly enjoys an orgasmic spanking. Not my kinda hanky-panky, but, as my Nana used to say, there's no accounting for taste. Anastasia, while dabbling in Christian's fetish out of curiosity, is decidedly against the whole submission thing, and even takes to domineering Mr. Grey sexually. So what's all the shouting about?

Picture
Read most genre fiction by men, your Patterson's, your Connelly's, your Grisham's and you will find the classic, degrading, sexualized females abounding, but no one is out there shouting about the evils of these books. Or the movies they are made into. Oh maybe a murmur here and there about Red Weddings and rape scenes. Maybe a chuckle about how official business matters are discussed in rooms filled with naked, panting prostitutes on basically any cable show. But hey, R. R. Martin's a genius, right? Patterson's the bread and butter of the publishing industry. The Soprano's was revolutionary. Don Draper's just misunderstood. They're men. It's art.

But a woman...a woman writing about sex...sex that involves red rooms and handcuffs between two consenting, albeit feeble minded and thinly drawn adults, that is a no-no. 

Picture
I am not saying these Grey books are good, either artistically or as a guide for what a healthy relationship, sexual or otherwise, looks like. What I'm saying is, what scares me more than the thought that women and girls may want to emulate Anastasia is that, as a society, we continue to shame the weak, the less powerful. And women are still in that boat. We point to any women who got tingles in her pants upon reading The Elevator Scene as wanton sluts, to be shunned by misogynists and feminists alike. Did you know that women used to be put in asylums for enjoying sex? People thought the female orgasm was a disease and called it hysteria. Look at that whore. Who does she think she is? She's out of her mind.

Want to talk about unhealthy attitudes about women? What would our world be like if the unfettered hate that has been unfurled upon 50 Shades was turned upon the porn industry? Or sex trafficking? While the Superbowl was sad for the Seahawks, it was horrific for the women forced to service the throngs of disappointed or jubilant men...

But don't get me started.

We can criticize the sexual ethics of 50 Shades all we want, but in the same breath we must recognize the deafening silence when the same stale, pathetic, swoony women are continuously and unabashedly displayed in fiction, television, and film created by men. And for all those women who like their sex and their reading hot around the edges? I hope you painted your bedroom red and posted it on Pintrest. No shame, baby. Oh...my. 

Picture
5 Comments
Jane Ryder
2/23/2015 12:11:17 am

Hear hear! Very well said. We also can't claim that women should have the freedom to be strong, feminist lesbians or quiet, asexual spinsters, or whatever the heck is their thing without also allowing women the freedom NOT to want to be those things, too. True sexual liberation means giving people the freedom to pursue whatever turns them on, as long as it doesn't involve non-consensual harm or doing things to children. That means hetero, homo, kinky, or vanilla.

I read this book that was basically the Kinsey Report redux, with info compiled not by asking people, but by reviewing their Internet habits. One of the points they drove home was that men respond to visual sexual stimuli, whereas women are more turned on by STORIES. Men are biologically hard-wired to respond quickly and easily to purely sexual characteristics, so they can fertilize lots and lots. (She has a vagina? I'll have sex with her right now!) Women are biologically hard-wired to size a guy up and decide whether or not he's worth investing in, especially since they can, you know, DIE from childbirth. This includes assessing appearance, ability to provide, emotional engagement, and a ton of other cues. He has a penis? Big deal. Can he bring home the mammoth meat and protect me from sabre-tooth tigers?

So I think a lot of the outcry over 50 Shades is because male authors (and critics, etc.) don't think of the sex scenes they write as pornographic, simply because written sex doesn't rev their motors. So when they're presented with a book that doesn't pretend to be about anything else, they're genuinely affronted. Especially when their wives are reading it and comparing them unfavorably to Christian Grey.

Not saying there isn't a huge and ridiculous double standard, and I'm certainly not excusing it; just saying they probably don't even realize just how insanely hypocritical they're really being.

My only problem with 50 Shades is that they're lousy from a craft point of view, and I've read better sex on Literotica.

Reply
Tina Schermer Sellers link
2/24/2015 03:46:00 am

Thanks Jenny! I was too busy doing a blog series on Sex Ed Made Easy and getting ready for a Couples Retreat to write a post on this ... Phew ... You nailed it! The slut-shaming was driving me crazy! Yada, yada, yada, and yes, yes, yes ... to all the arguments ... but let's look at the reality ... these books sold 1 million copies because women LOVE to be desired HARD. Vagina's cannot lie (see the sex research of Meana, Meston, Chivers and others or book: What Do Women Want?). Sorry if that bothers "you" (the slut shamers) ... it has driven a romance novel industry for years. Here's an idea, let's approach women's sexual fire with curiosity, openness and respect ... maybe we will learn something about this ageless wild power!

Reply
JL Spohr
2/24/2015 05:40:14 am

love it, Jane - thanks for your insightful comments as always!

Reply
JL Spohr
2/24/2015 05:41:10 am

Amen, Tina! Preach it!

Reply
Danny Stalder
3/17/2015 01:54:28 am

Fantastic blog, thank you for your insight and offering an other view if this commotion. Well said!

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Want updates? 
    Sign up!

    Archives

    January 2019
    June 2018
    December 2017
    April 2017
    November 2016
    October 2016
    June 2016
    July 2015
    April 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012

    Categories

    All
    Authors I Love
    Books For All Seasons
    Cancer
    Celebrities
    Contests
    England
    Food
    Grief
    Holidays
    Media
    Men
    Mental/physical Health
    Movies
    Musings
    My Books
    Parenthood
    Pop Culture
    Royals
    Scotland
    Spirituality
    The Patriarchy
    Writing

    RSS Feed